Looking for things to do on Kelleys Island? You’re in the right place.
This Lake Erie gem sits just a short ferry ride from the Ohio mainland, and I’ve spent years exploring every corner of it.
This guide walks you through 19 activities that make Kelleys Island worth your time. You’ll find historic sites, nature trails, family fun spots, and great places to eat.
Let’s get into what makes this island special and how to make the most of your visit.
Planning Your Trip to Kelleys Island
Getting to the island takes some planning, but it’s straightforward. The ferry runs year round from Marblehead, taking about 20 minutes and fitting cars, bikes, and walking passengers.
You can also book an air taxi or bring your own boat to the marina. Bikes work great, as the island covers just four square miles.
Golf carts are popular rentals, especially with families. You can bring your car on the ferry.
Summer weekends get crowded. Spring and fall offer quieter trails and lower prices. Day trips work if you start early.
Top Attractions and Activities on Kelleys Island
Glacial grooves, historic sites, nature preserves, family fun spots, and waterfront dining across the island.
1. Glacial Grooves State Memorial
The glaciers left their mark here 18,000 years ago. These grooves stretch 400 feet long and 35 feet wide. They’re the biggest accessible glacial grooves anywhere.
Wooden walkways let you get close without damaging the rock. Look for marine fossils pressed into the limestone. The site is free and takes about 30 minutes to find.
2. Kelleys Island State Park
This park gives you camping, trails, and Lake Erie access. The campground has over 100 sites with electric hookups. Day visitors use the picnic areas and beach.
Hiking trails wind through woods and along the shoreline. You can rent the Sherman Cabin or one of the yurts for a different camping experience.
The park makes a good base if you’re staying overnight.
3. East Quarry Trails & Horseshoe Lake
Old mining operations created this scenic spot. The trails loop around a former quarry that’s now a clear blue lake. Trees have grown back around the edges.
The water reflects the sky on calm days. It’s a quiet walk with good photo spots. The trail is mostly flat and takes about an hour to complete.
4. North Pond State Nature Preserve
Boardwalks take you into wetland habitat. This preserve protects important bird migration routes. The boardwalk keeps your feet dry while you watch for herons and egrets.
Spring and fall bring the most bird activity. The trails connect to other hiking paths if you want a longer walk. Bring binoculars and bug spray.
5. Abandoned Quarry Exploration
Limestone mining shaped this island’s history. Old quarry buildings still stand near the water filled pits. You can walk around the ruins and imagine the work that happened here.
The quarry lakes are clear but too deep for swimming. This site tells the story of the island’s industrial past. It’s free to find and good for history buffs.
6. Old Stone Church
This limestone church dates back to 1862. The building served as a church until the 1950s. Now it’s a small museum with local artifacts. The thick stone walls keep it cool inside.
You’ll see old photos and tools from early island life. Services occasionally still happen here in summer. Check the schedule before you visit.
7. Kelleys Island Historical Museum
Three buildings hold the island’s story. The museum covers Native American history, early settlers, and the fishing industry. You’ll find old photographs, tools, and household items.
The staff knows local stories and answers questions. Admission is by donation. It’s a good rainy day activity that takes about an hour.
8. North Shore Alvar State Preserve
This rare limestone habitat supports tough plants. Alvar ecosystems are uncommon worldwide. The thin soil over bedrock creates harsh growing conditions.
Only hardy plants survive here. The preserve protects this special environment. A short trail lets you see the flat limestone plains up close. Visit in spring when wildflowers bloom.
9. Herndon Sculpture Garden
Local artist Herndon created this outdoor gallery. Bronze sculptures dot the grounds, inspired by island life. Each piece has a story connected to Kelleys Island history.
The garden is free and open to visitors. You can walk among the art and take photos. It’s a peaceful spot that combines nature and creativity.
10. Charles Herndon Galleries
More of Herndon’s work fills this indoor space. The gallery shows paintings, sculptures, and photographs. Many pieces feature island scenes and Lake Erie.
You might meet the artist if you visit during open hours. The space is small but packed with interesting work. It’s free to browse and takes about 20 minutes.
11. Caddy Shack Square
This spot packs in family activities. The mini golf course has 18 holes with island themes. The arcade has classic games that kids love.
Small shops sell snacks, souvenirs, and beach gear. It’s the go-to place when you need to entertain children. Open seasonally, usually May through September.
12. Dipper Dan’s Ice Cream
Their cake batter flavor draws people back. This ice cream shop serves hand-dipped cones with lots of flavors. Lines get long on hot days, but they move fast.
They also have sundaes, shakes, and other frozen treats. It’s been an island favorite for years. Cash and cards both work.
13. Island Mining Company
Kids can mine for real gems here. You buy a bucket of mining rough and sift through it. The staff helps identify what you find. Children get to keep everything they discover.
It’s a hands-on activity that teaches about geology. Plan for 30 to 45 minutes. Good for ages 4 and up.
14. Rocky Beach
The shoreline here is perfect for rock hunting. Smooth stones cover this beach instead of sand. You’ll find interesting patterns and colors in the rocks.
It’s a calm spot for walking and collecting. The water is shallow near shore. Pack a bag for your favorite finds.
15. Scheele Preserve
This preserve combines beach and woods. The property includes Lake Erie frontage and forested trails. You can swim, walk the beach, or hike inland.
It’s less crowded than the state park beach. The preserve protects native plants and wildlife habitat. Free parking and access year-round.
16. Kayaking in Lake Erie
Paddling around the island gives you a different view. Several outfitters rent kayaks by the hour or day. You can circle the whole island if you have time and energy.
North Pond offers calmer water for beginners. The shoreline has interesting rock formations to find. Always check the weather before you go out.
17. Dockers Waterfront Bar & Restaurant
This spot serves fresh fish with lake views. The menu focuses on Lake Erie perch, walleye, and other seafood. The patio overlooks the water and catches the sunset.
They also have burgers and sandwiches if seafood isn’t your thing. It gets busy during dinner hours. Reservations help on weekends.
18. Caddy Shack Restaurant
Casual food works for families here. Pizza, wings, and salads make up most of the menu. Portions are big and prices are fair.
The atmosphere is relaxed and kid-friendly. You can eat inside or grab a table on the patio. They serve lunch and dinner during the season.
19. Monarch Winery Kelleys Island Wine Company
Local wines come from grapes grown on the island. The tasting room lets you sample different varieties. Tours show you the vineyard and explain the winemaking process.
You can buy bottles to take home. The outdoor seating area has views of the vines. Open afternoons most days, check the schedule.
Tips for Making the Most of Your Visit
Plan around the seasons and your interests.
- May and September offer warm weather without summer crowds. July and August are busiest but have the most services open. October brings fall colors to the trails. Winter is quiet but many businesses close
- Day trips should focus on four to five key sites like the Glacial Grooves, state park, and a restaurant. Weekend visitors can see everything at a relaxed pace. Three days let you really slow down and enjoy the quiet
- Families should hit Caddy Shack Square early before it gets crowded. Solo travelers love the quiet trails at North Pond and Scheele Preserve
- Nature enthusiasts should bring field guides for birds and plants to make the most of wildlife viewing opportunities
- Rent bikes first thing in the morning before they’re all taken, as availability decreases throughout the day
Conclusion
I’ve watched Kelleys Island charm thousands of visitors over the years. The glacial grooves always stop people in their tracks. The quiet trails and small-town feel keep them coming back.
Start with what interests you most. History buffs should hit the museums first. Nature lovers won’t want to miss the preserves. Families will find plenty to keep everyone happy.
Pack a day bag, grab a bike, and see what catches your attention.
Leave a comment below about what you’re most excited to see, or share this with someone planning an Ohio trip.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to see everything on Kelleys Island?
A full day covers the main sites if you keep moving. Two days let you find without rushing. Three days work well if you want to relax and really soak in the island pace.
Can you swim at Kelleys Island beaches?
Yes, several beaches allow swimming. The state park has the most popular beach with lifeguards in summer. Scheele Preserve and other spots offer quieter swimming areas along the shoreline.
Do you need a car on Kelleys Island?
No, bikes and golf carts work fine for most visitors. The island is small and easy to get around. You can bring a car on the ferry if you have mobility concerns or lots of gear.
What’s the best way to get to Kelleys Island?
The ferry from Marblehead runs year-round and takes about 20 minutes. It’s the most common option. Air taxis work if you’re in a hurry or coming from farther away.
Are dogs allowed on Kelleys Island?
Most outdoor areas welcome leashed dogs. The state park campground and trails allow pets. Check individual restaurants and shops for their pet policies before you go inside.